We have received 26 paper submissions to compete for the scholarships.  We have sent comments on    each paper by email.  The following is the list of awards:

First Prize:  ZHANG Nan  ￥15,000    (Sun Yat-Sen University)

Second Prize:  YU Haoyang  ￥ 8,000  (Renmin University of China)

Third Prize:

LIU Meng, ￥5,000  (Wuhan Univeristy)

Maura Ceci, ￥5,000  (Leiden Univeristy)

The attached are the comments and winning papers.   If you have any questions, please contact the        department of Philosophy:  027-68753566